Fifteen years ago, diversity and inclusion seemed like issues for an older generation to address. However, as I progressed through my career, I realized that diversity remained a significant concern, particularly in leadership. Many leaders viewed diversity as a mere compliance issue, not recognizing its potential as a competitive advantage. Determined to explore this further, I initiated a study with the Technical University of Munich to delve into the relationship between diversity and innovation.
Surveying 171 companies across Europe, we sought to determine how innovative they were and how diverse they were. Innovation revenue, the share of revenues generated from new products and services over the past three years, served as our innovation metric. Diversity was assessed based on six factors, including country of origin, age, and gender.
Our initial expectations were not particularly optimistic. However, the results proved to be overwhelmingly positive. Companies with greater diversity were simply more innovative. This was not merely a correlation; the data suggested a causal relationship between diversity and innovation, with both driving each other.
While our study primarily focused on Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, we are currently expanding it to include 1,600 companies across five additional countries. The initial results from this expanded study align with our original findings, reinforcing the positive correlation between diversity and innovation.
The media response to our findings was varied, ranging from factual reporting to sensationalist headlines. However, the attention generated by the study sparked discussions with senior executives eager to understand the implications of gender diversity, in particular.
In these discussions, I often encountered a sense of complacency, with executives believing that their organizations were not doing too badly in terms of diversity. However, our research revealed that having a single female board member, as was the case in some organizations, was insufficient to create a meaningful impact.
For gender diversity to positively affect innovation, a critical mass of women in leadership is essential. Our data showed that a threshold of 20% women in leadership was necessary to observe a significant increase in innovation revenue. Companies like Alibaba, JP Morgan, and Apple have already achieved this threshold and are reaping the benefits.
While some argue that diversity will improve over time, the reality is that progress has been painfully slow. Despite the increasing number of highly educated and experienced women, their representation in leadership roles has not kept pace. Education alone has not been enough to translate into significant leadership gains.
To address this disparity, we need to take proactive steps. Setting measurable targets, as SAP did with its goal of 25% women in leadership by 2017, is a critical first step. By setting clear goals, organizations can develop innovative strategies for developing leaders and expanding their recruitment pools.
The ultimate key to achieving greater diversity lies in two fundamental decisions made daily in every organization: who to hire and who to develop and promote. While programs and initiatives aimed at supporting women are valuable, it is these decisions that send the most powerful signals of change.
As a business advisor, my goal is not simply to advocate for diversity. It is to transform the face of leadership by making it more diverse. By embracing diversity, we create a truly inclusive environment where everyone has the opportunity to succeed.